I’m stepping out on my shaky limb today and speaking up about something that irks me. What is up with this trend of giving books negative reviews based on bias toward content? If you don’t want to read a violent murder scene, you should not purchase a suspense or thriller novel because that is likely what you will be reading. Censoring content is up to the reader, not the writer.
All of my novels and short stories fall somewhere in the mystery/suspense/thriller genre. This is a broad category that includes everything from the cozy mystery, which is the mild whodunit that downplays violence, to the heart-thumping crime thriller that feeds off issues like violence, murder and revenge. In between, you’ll find romantic suspense, paranormal mysteries, psychological suspense, supernatural thrillers and more. The mystery/suspense/thriller genre encompasses a broad spectrum of writing and not every book written within this genre will please fans of specific subgenres. But this is not the writer’s fault.
The writer’s responsibility is to craft the best story he/she can, while remaining true to the plot and the characters. If I am writing about gang members or serial killers, chances are slim that I’ll fit into the cozy mystery subgenre. Writers know this and readers need to, as well.
While I have had some negative reviews based on the reader’s dislike of the violence and/or language in a few of my books, those reviews did not trigger today’s rant. You see, I am not only a writer. I am an avid reader and reviewer. I read a wide variety of subjects but mystery/suspense/thriller has always been my favorite fiction genre. I enjoy everything from mild cozy mysteries to graphic thrillers. Content doesn’t offend me, providing it fits the writing style, plot and characters. I want to make that clear because I am not a fan of gratuitous violence or graphic scenes used merely for shock.
I’m aware when I pick up a book labeled as a thriller that I’m stepping into dark territory. The choice to do so is mine alone. I am responsible for reading the product description and deciding whether I want to enter that writer’s world. Lately, I’ve been reading negative reviews for suspense and thriller novels that I’ve loved, only to find that the sole issue the reader had was violent content. This is completely unfair to the writer.
I would not purchase a book within the erotica genre, then give it a poor rating based on the sex being too graphic. Nor would I purchase a fantasy novel, only to write a review slamming it for being too fantastical. But these genres make it easier for readers to predict content. We all know that erotica will contain graphic sex. We also expect that a fantasy novel will take place in a made-up world.
The mystery/suspense/thriller genre is a gigantic playground made up of innocent children on a swing set and bodies buried in the sandbox. Anything could be lurking in the shadows or standing out in bright sunshine. For those who are offended by content, it is vital to play close attention to plot description and subgenre. You must approach this wide genre with this understanding. Choose your reading material wisely. If the plot description tells you there are serial killers, hit men, mafia, gang activity and/or murderers running loose, be aware that violence, to some degree, will be a part of the story. Please do not slam a book and its author for not living up to your personal censoring requirements.



